TP-Link Omada SG3428 (24-Port Gigabit) vs Ubiquiti Networks USW-24-POE (Gigabit Layer 2 Ethernet Switch)
The Good
- Seamless integration into Omada Software Defined Networks.
- Offers extensive management features, including a familiar CLI interface.
- Operates silently, making it suitable for noise-sensitive environments.
- Provides excellent value and performance for its feature set.
The Bad
- Multiple reports of units arriving dead on arrival or failing quickly.
- Lacks Power over Ethernet (PoE) output, leading to buyer confusion.
- Some users experienced difficulty with Omada controller adoption or stability issues.
The Good
- Exceptional reliability and consistent, long-term performance
- Fanless design ensures silent operation, ideal for various environments
- Seamless integration and centralized management within the UniFi ecosystem
- Solid build quality and high-quality hardware
The Bad
- Limited 1 Gigabit SFP uplinks with no 10 Gigabit SFP+ support
- Management requires a UniFi controller, posing challenges for standalone use or remote troubleshooting
- Can run warm under heavy PoE loads, requiring adequate ventilation
- PoE budget and port count (16 out of 24) may be insufficient for some demanding setups
This switch is a solid choice for those deeply invested in the TP-Link Omada ecosystem seeking advanced network control, provided they are prepared for potential initial setup challenges and acknowledge the reported concerns regarding product reliability.
Read the full TP-Link Omada SG3428 (24-Port Gigabit) consensus →This switch is an excellent choice for users deeply embedded in the UniFi ecosystem who prioritize silent operation and robust reliability for their Gigabit networks. Potential buyers should consider its 1 Gigabit uplink limitation and UniFi-centric management before purchase.
Read the full Ubiquiti Networks USW-24-POE (Gigabit Layer 2 Ethernet Switch) consensus →Our pick: Ubiquiti Networks USW-24-POE (Gigabit Layer 2 Ethernet Switch) · 7.7/10
Owners rate the Ubiquiti Networks USW-24-POE (Gigabit Layer 2 Ethernet Switch) meaningfully higher — 7.7/10 against 6.4/10 for the TP-Link Omada SG3428 (24-Port Gigabit). It wins where it counts: Reliability & Endurance and Stability.
ORA Metrics may earn a commission on qualifying purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you.