MikroTik CRS112-8P-4S-IN (8-Port Gigabit PoE Switch) vs TP-Link Omada SG3428 (24-Port Gigabit)
The Good
- Offers strong value for hardware quality, especially for experienced MikroTik users.
- Supports both 24VDC and 48VDC PoE devices with the right power supply.
- Provides extensive configuration options through RouterOS for network engineers.
- Fanless design for silent operation.
The Bad
- Requires a separate, costly 48VDC power supply for proper PoE functionality.
- Performance severely degrades when using advanced features like VLANs.
- Not a plug-and-play device, demanding a steep learning curve for RouterOS newcomers.
- SFP ports can be quirky and may require manual configuration.
The Good
- Seamless integration into Omada Software Defined Networks.
- Offers extensive management features, including a familiar CLI interface.
- Operates silently, making it suitable for noise-sensitive environments.
- Provides excellent value and performance for its feature set.
The Bad
- Multiple reports of units arriving dead on arrival or failing quickly.
- Lacks Power over Ethernet (PoE) output, leading to buyer confusion.
- Some users experienced difficulty with Omada controller adoption or stability issues.
While offering advanced configurability for MikroTik veterans, this switch is not recommended for users needing reliable PoE without extra cost or those expecting full performance with managed features like VLANs.
Read the full MikroTik CRS112-8P-4S-IN (8-Port Gigabit PoE Switch) consensus →This switch is a solid choice for those deeply invested in the TP-Link Omada ecosystem seeking advanced network control, provided they are prepared for potential initial setup challenges and acknowledge the reported concerns regarding product reliability.
Read the full TP-Link Omada SG3428 (24-Port Gigabit) consensus →Our pick: TP-Link Omada SG3428 (24-Port Gigabit) · 6.4/10
Owners rate the TP-Link Omada SG3428 (24-Port Gigabit) meaningfully higher — 6.4/10 against 4.5/10 for the MikroTik CRS112-8P-4S-IN (8-Port Gigabit PoE Switch). It wins where it counts: Value for Money and Stability.
ORA Metrics may earn a commission on qualifying purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you.