Mikrotik CCR2004-1G-12S+2XS (High-Performance Ethernet Router) vs Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter 10X (10-Port Gigabit Router)
The Good
- Delivers exceptional throughput and performance for high-speed internet and demanding home lab environments.
- Features an impressive array of 10G and 25G SFP ports, offering excellent connectivity options.
- Provides a rich set of software capabilities, including built-in Wireguard and advanced routing features.
- Offers significant value for money, providing enterprise-grade functionality at a competitive price point.
The Bad
- Requires substantial IT knowledge and a steep learning curve for configuration and full utilization.
- Lacks a dedicated switch chip, meaning all inter-port traffic passes through the CPU, which can limit concurrent utilization of all ports.
- Some users reported minor reboot issues that can be resolved with specific modifications.
The Good
- Delivers excellent network throughput and speeds, often matching or exceeding ISP-provided bandwidth.
- Offers a generous number of Ethernet ports, consolidating network equipment for many users.
- Provides a rich set of advanced configuration options, including deep packet inspection and fail-over.
- Runs cool and efficiently, with a responsive interface for those familiar with networking.
The Bad
- Several owners reported issues with the router locking up, requiring reboots, or failing entirely after a few months.
- The user interface and configuration process are often described as complex and not plug-and-play for non-technical users.
- Some users experienced limitations with PoE functionality, specifically 24V output, and lack of full jumbo frame support.
- Customer support is frequently cited as unhelpful, often directing users to community forums for assistance.
This router is an excellent choice for experienced network professionals or enthusiasts seeking a high-performance, feature-rich device for demanding home lab or SOHO environments. Its robust capabilities and connectivity come with the expectation of a deep technical understanding for setup and management.
Read the full Mikrotik CCR2004-1G-12S+2XS (High-Performance Ethernet Router) consensus →This router is a solid choice for technically-minded users seeking advanced control and high performance for their wired network, provided they are prepared for a steep learning curve and potential reliability concerns. Less experienced users may find the setup and troubleshooting too demanding.
Read the full Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter 10X (10-Port Gigabit Router) consensus →Our pick: Mikrotik CCR2004-1G-12S+2XS (High-Performance Ethernet Router) · 9.3/10
Owners rate the Mikrotik CCR2004-1G-12S+2XS (High-Performance Ethernet Router) meaningfully higher — 9.3/10 against 5.8/10 for the Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter 10X (10-Port Gigabit Router). It wins where it counts: Value for Money and Reliability & Endurance.
ORA Metrics may earn a commission on qualifying purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you.